Blind Spots: Australia’s hidden decommissioning risks

A report looking at Australia’s legal regime which has fundamental design flaws in relation to the collection and distribution of oil and gas information, which imposes risks on both the environment and the public purse.


In this report

All references and author details are available in the full pdf report version


1 – Key Findings

Australia’s legal regime has fundamental design flaws in relation to the collection and distribution of oil and gas information, which imposes risks on both the environment and the public purse.


A transparent regime ensures that regulators act in accordance with their public mandates rather than serving regulated entities. Transparency is a cornerstone of international environmental law and crucial to resource management, risk management and the protection of taxpayers and the environment. Transparency is particularly important for effective regulation of oil and gas decommissioning, given the risks associated with late-life assets.

The Crown owns Australia’s oil and gas resources on behalf of the public. It follows that the public has a right to understand how the government manages these resources, and to scrutinise its laws and policies, including on taxation, decommissioning and licensing. This requires the public to have access to information about production, ownership and decommissioning liabilities and whether operators have the financial capacity to meet them.

Failure to collect data

Australia routinely fails to collect the information most relevant to decommissioning risks. Actual decommissioning costs are not systematically collected, detailed decommissioning planning comes too late in the asset life cycle, and information on operators’ financial capacity or security arrangements remains scarce.

As a result, Australian regulators have very limited visibility into whether operators can actually pay for clean-up. Robust financial security requirements for oil and gas decommissioning overseas, both in the US and onshore in Australia’s Victoria and Northern Territory, show that imposing robust requirements is not bad for business but is necessary for effective decommissioning. And while financial capability assessments are a black box in Australia, other jurisdictions including Alberta (Canada) publish an aggregate picture of risk and exposure.

“As a result, Australian regulators have very limited visibility into whether operators can actually pay for clean-up.”

Disclosure prohibition

Much of the information that regulators do collect cannot be disclosed due to an effective prohibition on disclosure of any information that could be considered commercially confidential. Changes to the Commonwealth’s offshore regime in March 2026, implemented to strengthen oversight and improve transparency, failed to deal with this problematic prohibition. Australia justifies the permanent confidentiality of certain categories of information, including disaggregated production data, information on financial security and financial capability, and operator- or asset-level decommissioning cost estimates, on the basis that it would harm industry if made public. However, much of this data is already available from commercial data providers such as Rystad, for a fee. Therefore, the regime does not actually protect company information from competitors; all it does is hinder public scrutiny.

We find that even when information is disclosed, this disclosure is often too delayed, discretionary or inaccessible to enable effective scrutiny.

Less transparency than peer jurisdictions

Importantly, our comparative analysis shows that Australia is significantly less transparent than peer jurisdictions, including the UK, Canada and the US. Other jurisdictions acknowledge the importance of public scrutiny by designing transparent regimes that lift the lid on the activities of industry. Oil and gas companies, including those operating in Australia, already operate in markets where publication of information on production, decommissioning and financials is routine. There is no reason not to make publication of this information routine in Australia as well. The more transparent regimes in other countries demonstrate that greater transparency is both practical and compatible with a successful petroleum industry.


Recommendations

1. Lift the blanket ban on disclosure

Proposal
Remove the Commonwealth’s disproportionate prohibition on the public disclosure of information that could adversely affect entities’ commercial, business or financial affairs, or information about their financial resources.

Rationale
The definition of ‘permanently confidential information’ is drafted so widely that it has the potential to capture most information that is useful to stakeholders, such as operator- or asset-level production volumes. Disaggregated information is available in other jurisdictions without resulting in tangible adverse impact to the owners or operators. Greater transparency is needed to promote accountability.

2. Enhance the transparency of decommissioning costs

Proposal
Collect and disclose estimated and actual decommissioning costs through a regularly updated and public decommissioning plan, across Commonwealth, state and territory regimes.

Rationale
Currently, regulators and other stakeholders lack visibility into operators’ decommissioning costs, plans and timing. Recent defaults point to the need for transparency to avert decommissioning disasters, particularly for risky late-life operators

3. Make operators’ financial capacity to pay for clean-up visible

Proposal
Collect additional financial information from operators to assess their capability to pay for decommissioning costs in the Commonwealth, and publish the regulator’s assessment methodology and results.

Rationale
Transparency is crucial to effective financial assurance. However, the Commonwealth’s financial capability regime is insufficient, leaving regulators and stakeholders in the dark over operators’ ability to settle their end-of-life costs and the resulting default risks that can shift costs onto taxpayers.

4. Publish operators’ decommissioning pre-funding information

Proposal
Create a public register listing the nature and amount of financial security held by operators to cover their end-of-life clean-up costs.

Rationale
Visibility into the financial security held by industry is crucial to managing the risk of decommissioning defaults.

5. Make regulatory disclosure mandatory, not discretionary

Proposal
Require (rather than permit) regulators to publish disclosable information, across Commonwealth, state and territory regimes, including automatic publication of information that becomes disclosable after a limited period of confidentiality.

Rationale
Mandatory disclosure would force regulators to update and maintain comprehensive public databases and registers. This would resolve existing data accessibility, delay and fragmentation issues.


Next
Next

Decommissioning Defaults: The risks of late-life oil and gas assets