Conclusion
Key observations and recommendations to address the flaws in Australia’s
legal regime.
Blind Spots
This paper identifies fundamental design flaws in Australia’s legal regime with respect to the collection and distribution of information on oil- and gas-producing assets – and exposes the risks this creates for the environment and the public purse.
Key observations
Australia collects the basics, but does not collect the data needed
to manage the significant risks associated with decommissioning.Regulators have limited visibility over whether operators can actually pay for clean-up.
Much of the information regulators do collect cannot be disclosed due to an effective prohibition on disclosure of any information that is ‘permanently confidential information’, which can include information considered to be commercially sensitive.
Even disclosed information is often too fragmented, delayed or inaccessible to enable effective scrutiny.
Australia is materially less transparent than comparable mature petroleum jurisdictions.
This undermines the case for commercial confidentiality.
Given the public ownership of petroleum resources, there is a clear rationale for public transparency into how the Commonwealth, state and territory governments manage these resources. Stakeholder scrutiny is paramount to effective regulation.
As set out in the Key Findings, this paper recommends the following actions:
1. Lift the blanket ban on disclosure;
2. Enhance the transparency of decommissioning costs;
3. Make operators’ financial capacity to pay for clean-up visible;
4. Publish operators’ decommissioning pre-funding information; and,
5. Make regulatory disclosure mandatory, not discretionary.
“In particular, greater transparency would have helped to protect the public and ensure better regulation of petroleum resources, particularly in relation to Australia’s mounting decommissioning problem.”